We use cookies to enhance your experience on our website. By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. You can change your cookie settings at any time.
Find out more
Jump to Content
Jump to Main Navigation
User Account
Personal Profile
See all online law products
More
About
Subscriber Services
Take a Tour
FAQs
Help
Contact Us
Search
Browse all
Geographic regions
Geographic Regions
Africa
Americas
Antarctic Region
Asia
Europe
Oceania
Jurisdictions
Content type
Constitutional instruments and materials
Current constitutions
Constitutional amendments
Constitutional foundation documents
Constitutionally related documents
National instruments and materials
National legislation
Commentary and analysis
Book content
Encyclopedia entries
Bibliographies
Constitutional overviews (by jurisdiction)
Chronologies
Notes
US State
United States [us]
Alabama
Alaska
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
District of Columbia
Florida
Georgia
Hawaii
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kansas
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
North Dakota
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
United States Minor Outlying Islands [um]
United States Freely Associated States
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming
Subject
Constitutional history
Constitutional law and processes
Cultures and people
Legal system
Policy areas
Politics and government
Rights
The state
My Content
(0)
Recently viewed
(0)
Save Entry
My Searches
(0)
Recently viewed
(0)
Save Search
Print
Save
Cite
Email this content
Share Link
Copy this link, or click below to email it to a friend
Email this content
or copy the link directly:
https://oxcon.ouplaw.com/abstract/10.1093/law/9780190627645.001.0001/law-9780190627645-miscMatter-9
The link was not copied. Your current browser may not support copying via this button.
Link copied successfully
Copy link
Sign in
You could not be signed in, please check and try again.
Username
Please enter your Username
Password
Please enter your Password
Forgot password?
Don't have an account?
Sign in via your Institution
You could not be signed in, please check and try again.
Sign in with your library card
Please enter your library card number
View translated passages only
Oxford Law Citator
Contents
Expand All
Collapse All
Preliminary Material
Contents
Detailed Contents
Preface
Editors’ Note on the Transliteration
Main Text
Introduction
Prologue: Constitutional Debates in the Arab Spring
I Introduction
II Aborted Transition Processes in Libya and Yemen
III Egypt: The Winner Takes All
IV Tunisia: The Difficult Art Of Political Compromise
V Conclusions
Part 1 Power and Legitimacy
1.1 The Legitimacy of Constitution-Making Processes in the Arab World: An Islamic Perspective
I Introduction
II Constitutions and Constitutionalism
III Islamic Legitimacy of Constitution-Making in the Arab World
IV The Secular State as Framework for Mediation of Paradox
1.2 Legitimacy of Constitution-making Processes: Reflections from the Perspective of International Law
I Introduction: Sovereignty of States—A Limitation to Any Attempt to Influence the Procedure of Constitution-Making as Well as the Content of a New Constitution
II Human Rights and Other International Standards as Potential Limitations for Constitution-Making
A Introduction
B Standards Concerning the Procedure of Constitution-making
1 In General
2 Preparation of the First Draft of a Constitution
3 Adoption of the Constitution
4 International Standards Concerning the Content of Constitutions
III Conclusions
1.3 Regimes’ Legitimacy Crises in International Law: Libya, Syria, and Their Competing Representatives
I Introduction
II External Legitimacy and Representation from an International Legal Perspective
III Manifestations and Sanctions of Governmental Illegitimacy
A Recognition as a Government vs. Recognition as a Legitimate Representative
B Mechanical Accreditation vs. Legitimacy-Appraisals in Multilateral Fora
IV Concluding Remarks: Diversification vs. Legalization
1.4 The Process of Institutional Transformation in Tunisia after the Revolution
I Introduction
II Difficulties Confronting Tunisian Institutional and Democratic Change
A Difficulties Linked to the Revolution
B The Risks of an Islamist-majority Government
III The Political, Constitutional, and Democratic Changes Stemming from the Transitional Process
A The Emergence of an Independent Civil Society
B Multiplication and Structuring of Parties after the Revolution
C The Constitution of January 27, 2014
1 The Process of Adoption of the New Constitution
2 The 2014 Constitution Viewed from the Perspective of Constitutional History
3 Form and Contents of the New Constitution
4 Appraisement and Criticism
IV Conclusion: The End of the Transitional Process Through the Parliamentary and Presidential Elections at the End of 2014
A The Parliamentary Elections
B The Presidential Elections
1.5 Religious Authorities and Constitutional Reform: The Case of Al-Azhar in Egypt
I Introduction
II Evolution of Al-Azhar’s Relation Toward the Sovereign Power
III Islamic Principles on Statehood: Lacking Textual Provisions and Consequences
A Islam and the Concepts of Nation-State and Constitutionalism
B Jurisprudents and Scholars Integrating Themselves within Power
IV Evolution and Influence of Al-Azhar’s Constitutional Ideologies
A Comparing Al-Azhar’s Constitutional Visions: The 1979 Draft Constitution and Its 2011 “Document on the Future of Egypt”
B Explaining Al-Azhar’s Ideological Shift
C The Impact of the 2011 Al-Azhar Document on the Constitutions of 2012 and 2014
V Conclusion
Annexes
A Al-Azhar Declaration on the Future of Egypt (2011)
Al-Azhar Declaration on the Future of Egypt
B Al-Azhar Statement on Basic Freedoms (2012)
Al-Azhar Statement on Basic Freedoms
First: The Freedom of Belief
Second: Freedom of Opinion and Expression
Third: Freedom of Scientific Research
Fourth: Freedom of Literary and Artistic Creativity
C Al-Azhar Draft Constitution of 1979
s.1: The Islamic Community
s.2: The Foundation of Islamic Society
s.3: Islamic Economy
s.4: Individual Rights and Freedoms
s.5: The imām
Section 6: The Judiciary
s.7: Consultation, Monitoring, and Enacting Laws
s.8: The Government
s.9: General and Transitional Rules
Resolution no. 11 of the Shaykh of Al-Azhar; dated the 25th of Muḥarram 1398 h. of January 5, 1978 C.
Resolution no. 12 of the Shaykh of Al-Azhar; dated the 25th of Muḥarram, 1398 h. of January 5, 1978 C.
1.6 The Arab Spring and Constitutional Reforms in Jordan: A Historical and Legal Appraisal
I Introduction
II A Brief Historical Review of Jordan’s Constitutions
A The Constitution of 1928
B The Constitution of 1947
C The Constitution of 1952
III Political, Social, and Ideological Developments Since the Inception of the Emirate
A Political Developments
B Economic and Social Developments
C Ideological Developments
D The Election of 1989
IV The Constitutional Amendments of 2011
A The Constitutional Court
B The Independent Electoral Commission
C Provisional Laws
D The Dissolution of Parliament
E Infringement of the Rights of Jordanians (Arts. 7 and 8)
F The State Security Court
G The Provision of Art. 128
H Arts. 34, 35, and 36 on the Rights of the King
V Developments After the Constitutional Amendments
VI The Constitutional Amendment of 2014
VII Conclusion
1.7 Winter Is Coming: Authoritarian Constitutionalism under Strain in the Gulf
I Not Just Ornaments
II The Parliamentary Conundrum
A The First Generation: The Constitutions of Independence (1960s–1970s)
1 Kuwait (1961)
2 Qatar (1970 and 1972)
3 The United Arab Emirates (1971)
4 Bahrain (1973)
B The Second Generation: Codifying Practice (1990s)
1 Saudi Arabia (1992)
2 Oman (1996)
C The Third Generation: The Conservative Convergence (2000s)
1 Bahrain (2002)
2 Qatar (2004)
D Uprisings and the Quick Fix: Elections and/or Constitutional Amendments? (2011)
1 The Omani Amendments
2 The Kuwaiti Elections
3 The Bahraini Amendments
III Winter is Coming
1.8 Constitutional Reform in Oman: Rights Granted under Reserve
I Introduction
II The GCC and Oman’s Constitutions: A Very brief Outlook
III Historical Background
IV Early Omani “Constitutional Monarchy”
V Oman’s 1996 Basic Statute of the State
VI The Constitutional Amendments of 2011 and a Constitutional Monarchy
VII Conclusion
Part 2 What Basis for Statehood: Religion or Citizenship?
2.1 Al-Dawlah al-Madanīyah: A Concept to Reconcile Islam and Modern Statehood?
I Origins and Development Of the Notion of Al-Dawlah Al-MadanĪyah
II Al-Dawlah Al-MadanĪyah in Context of the Arab Spring
III Constitutional Relevance of Al-Dawlah Al-MadanĪyah
IV Conclusion
2.2 Islam and the Constitutional State: Are They in Contradiction?
I Introduction
II The Achievements: Tunisia as the “Exception”?
III The Obstacles to the Establishment of a Constitutional State
A Revival of Art. 1 of the Constitution
B What Protections Are There for a Democratic and Constitutional State?
1 The Civil Nature of the State
2 Islam’s Position in the Constitutional and Legal System
3 Freedom of Religion and Belief and the Separation of Religion and Politics
4 The Place of the International Conventions
IV Conclusion
2.3 State and Religion in the Aftermath of the Arab Uprisings
I The “Arab Spring”: Europe as a Model for Change
II Structural Crisis of the Arab Political and Economic Power
III Democracy and the Relationship Between State and Religion
IV In Search of a Role Model
V Conclusion
2.4 The Relationship between Constitutions, Politics, and Islam: A Comparative Analysis of the North African Countries
I Introduction
II Implosion, Eclipse, and Come-Back in Politics
III An Essential Reference, a Diversified Content
IV Reference to Islam and The Devolution of Power in Religious Matters
A Egypt
B Tunisia
C Morocco
V Conclusion: SharĪʿah as an Ideology
2.5 Contesting Islamic Constitutionalism after the Arab Spring: Islam in Egypt’s Post-Mubārak Constitutions
I Background: Classical and Modern Islamic Legal Theory
A Islamic Law before Modern Times: The Formation of a Sunni Consensus and Elaboration of Traditional Sunni Law
B Modernity and the Collapse of the Sunni Consensus
1 Neotraditionalist
2 Salafī
3 Modernist
4 Secularist
II Islamic Law in Egypt’s Constitutions Before the Arab Spring
A Religious Reticence in Egypt’s First National Constitutions 1923–1971
B The Evolution of Provisions Governing Islam in Egypt’s 1971 Constitution
III Contesting Islam After the Fall of MubĀrak
A State and Islam in the 2012 Constitution
B State and Islam in the 2014 Constitution
IV Back to the Future?
2.6 The Caliphate State: A Basis of Modern Statehood?
I Introduction
II The Precursor to the Caliphate
III Essential Characteristics of the Classical (Premodern) KhilĀfah or ImĀmah
IV The Islamic State: Legitimate Governance and Rule in Islamic Law
V Principles of Governance in an Islamic State
VI Conclusion: Can the Islamic Model of Statehood Offer Anything of Value to Modern States that Espouse the Centrality of Islam in the Public Realm of the State?
Part 3 What Kind of Government: Civilian or Military?
3.1 State Control over the Military or Military Control over the State?: A Comparison of Selected Arab Constitutions
I Introduction
II Tunisia: From Authoritarian to Democratic Control of the Armed Forces
A The Military and Its Constitutional Status before the Revolution
B Military Support for the Revolution and the Drafting of a New Constitution
C The Military and Its Constitutional Status after the Revolution
III Egypt: Triumph of the Military Over the Civil State
A The Military and Its Constitutional Status before the Uprising
B The SCAF as Ruler and Pouvoir Constituant
C The 2012 Constitution and the Coup against President Mursī
D 2014: Another Constitution for the Deepest of All Arab States
IV Syria: Staunch Support for the Regime
A The Military and Its Constitutional Status before the Arab Spring
B Civil-Military Relations during the Uprising and the Civil War
C The 2012 Constitution and Syria’s Military
V Yemen: Progressive Constitution-Making Vs. Military Disintegration and ḤŪthĪ Rebellion
A The Military and Its Constitutional Status before the Uprising
B President Ṣāliḥ’s Ouster and the National Dialogue Conference
C Theory and Reality: The 2015 Draft Constitution and the Ḥūthī Rebellion
VI Libya: Total Loss of Control
A The Military and Its Constitutional (Non-)Status before the Revolution
B From Uprising into the Civil War
C Constitution-making: Killed in Action
D The Libyan National Army and Its Constitutional (Non-)Status as of 2015
VII Conclusion and Outlook
3.2 Changes in Civil-Military Relationships after the Arab Spring
I Introduction: Change in Motion?
II What is the Military in the Middle East?: From Constitutional Considerations to the Role of the Military in Authoritarian Settings
III Time of Change in 2011: Mass Mobilizations as an Essential “Stress Test” for Armies
IV Transitional Settings and the Military: Tunisia, Egypt, and Beyond
A The Tunisian Case—The Military as a Safeguard of the Transition Process
B The Egyptian Case—The Military Elephant in the Porcelain Shop of Egyptian Politics
C The Yemeni Case—Incoherent Military Structures, Fragmentation, and Instability
D The Libyan Case—Weak Military, Localism and Competing Militias
E The Syrian Case: The End of the Syrian Military?
V How to Reassemble the Pieces Together? Transitions in Institutional Terms
A From the Specific Tunisian Case to Protecting the Military’s Prerogatives Elsewhere
B The Case of Egypt: From Apparent Extrication to Military Tutelage
C The Military and Egyptian Constitutions
D Reinstating a Monopoly on “Legitimate Violence” or Falling into the Traps of Civil War in Libya and Yemen?
E Hijacking Transition in Egypt: A Return to Military-led Government or the End of Any Prospects for Democratic Control of the Armed Forces?
VI Conclusion
3.3 The Changing Role of the Military in Mauritania
I Introduction
II The Implication of the Conflict Between the Al-BidĀn and the Black-African Population
III The Military and Their Role in Confronting Crises
A The Military and the Western Sahara Crisis
B The Military and Environmental Crises
IV The Power of the Military in the Context of Government
A The Impact of Military Coups d’État in Mauritania
B External Factors Influencing the Military’s Role in Government, Leading to Internal Reform
V Conclusion
3.4 The Grip of the Army on Algeria’s Political System
I Introduction
II The Circumstances Leading to the Army’s Grip on the Algerian Political System
A The Army’s Role in the Nationalist Movement and during the Fight for Independence
B The Frontier Army Marches towards the Control of Power after Independence
III How the Political System Works
A The Army’s Grip on the System of Government
B The Army’s Grip on the Multiparty Political System: The Cosmetic Democracy
IV Conclusion
3.5 The Role of the Army in a Multicommunity Society: The Case of Lebanon
I Introduction
II Political Attitudes Toward the Army
A Contrition
B Mistrust
C Frustration among Military Personnel
III The Six Schools and their Common Denominator
A Demoralization of the Army
B Concern for the Unity of the Army
C The Army Subordinate to the Politicians
D The Army as Broom
E The Army as Militia
F The Army as Taxi
IV The Army, Protector of Sovereignty
Part 4 The Fragile Basis of Democracy and Development
4.1 The Anatomy of the Arab Spring (2011–2015)
I Introduction
II Historical Context
III Evolution of the Arab Identity
IV Nationalism and the Rise of Islamism
V Identity and violence
VI Economic Failure
VII Geopolitical Factors, Exceptionalism, and Double Standards
VIII Assessing the “Arab Spring” Outcomes
4.2 The Difficult Path toward Democracy: New Electoral Systems in Egypt, Libya, and Tunisia
I Introduction
II Conquering Democracy: The Challenge of Organizing Free, Fair, and Transparent Elections
A A Credible Electoral Process Overseen by an Independent Electoral Authority
B Competitive Elections
III Expressing Democracy: The Test of Choosing a Voting System
A A Resounding Rejection of the Strict Majority Option
1 Tunisia
2 Egypt
3 Libya
B The Goal of Proportionality, Variously Expressed
1 Tunisia
2 Egypt
3 Libya
IV Consolidating Democracy: The Ultimate Test of Exercising Power
A Majorities Put to the Test by the Exercise of Transitional Power
1 Tunisia
2 Libya
3 Egypt
B Majorities Face the Test of the Exercise of Constituent Power
1 The Elaboration of Constitutions: A Process “Peppered” with Uncertainties
2 Constitutional Debates Characterized by Points of Tension
4.3 Centralized or Decentralized State Structures?: Tendencies in the Arab Transition States
I Introduction
II The Limited Attention Paid to the Issue of Decentralization
III Centralization or Decentralization: The Possible Combinations
A Transition
B The Role Played by Subnational Structures
C Boundaries
D Trust
E Rights and Freedoms
F Capacity Building of Subnational Structures
IV Conclusion
4.4 The Legal Status of the Kurds in Iraq and Syria
I The Kurds as a People and as a Minority
II Status of Ethnic and Religious Minorities Under Islamic Law
III The Legal Status of Kurds and Kurdish Territory in Iraq
A The Mūṣul Question
B Recognition of the Kurds during the British Mandate
C Obligations of the Iraqi State under the League of Nations
D The Legal Status of Kurds in the Republic of Iraq
E The Legal Status of the Kurds after the 2003 Occupation of Iraq by the US-led Coalition
IV Unresolved Issues Between Baghdad and ArbĪl
A Federal and Regional Competencies
B Oil and Gas Issues
C Kirkūk and Other Disputed Areas
V The Legal Status of Kurds in Syria
VI Closing Words
4.5 The Separation and Distribution of Powers under the New Moroccan Constitution
I Introduction
II The Distribution of Powers Before the 2011 Constitution
III The Reform of the “Old” Art. 19: the End of the “Confusion” Between Temporal Power and Spiritual Power?
IV Separation of Powers and the Form of Government: Toward the Establishment of a Parliamentary Monarchy?
A The Strengthening of the Government’s Powers
B The King Reigns and Governs
C An “Ultimate Leader” and a “Second-in-Command”
V The Legislative Power: The Parliament, the Government, and a (Lame) King-Legislator
VI Judicial Power, Constitutional Justice, and the King’s “Interference”
VII Concluding Remarks
4.6 The Quest for a New Economic Order in Egypt’s Constitutional Transformation
I The Arab Spring and the Quest for a New Economic Order
II The Economic Paradox of the 1971 Constitution
III Neoliberal Reform and Constitutional Justice
IV The Economic Debates in the Constitutional Process
A The Economic Demands
B Competing Ideologies
V Economic Principles in the Constitutions of 2012 and 2014
A General Principles
B Property
C Taxation
D Industrial Relations
E Economic Rights
VI Conclusion
Part 5 Liberty, Equality, and The Rights of Minorities
5.1 International Human Rights Law as a Framework for Emerging Constitutions in Arab Countries
I Introduction
II Human Rights in the Existing Constitutions of Arab Countries
III The Effect of Islam on the Human Rights Provisions of the Constitutions of Arab States
A Equality of Rights
B Gender Equality
C Religious Equality
D Penal Law
IV Conclusion
5.2 Civil and Political Rights as a Precondition for Democratic Participation
I Preface
II Introduction
III Part I: Nature of Civil and Political Rights
A Research Topic I: Nature of Civil and Political Rights
B Research Topic II: Enforcement Mechanism of Civil and Political Rights
1 Requirement I: Enforcement Mechanism of Civil and Political Rights at the International Level
2 Requirement II: Enforcement Mechanism of Civil and Political Rights at the Regional Level
a European Convention on Human Rights
b American Convention on Human Rights
c African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights
d Arab Charter on Human Rights
IV Part Ii: Enforcement of Civil and Political Rights Contributes to Democratic Participation
A Research Topic I: Arab States and How They Honor Civil and Political Rights
1 Requirement I: Arab States’ Participation in the Preparation of the Two International Covenants on Human Rights
2 Requirement II Arab States’ Commitment to Honoring Civil and Political Rights
B Research Topic II: Guaranteeing Civil and Political Rights and Democratic Participation
1 Requirement I: Democracy
a Concept of “Democracy”
b Democracy Enforcement Forms
c Key Areas for Promoting Enforcement of Democracy
2 Requirement II: Activation of Democratic Participation through Enforcement of Political Rights
V Conclusion
5.3 Citizenship Rights in Selected Arab Constitutions
I Introduction
II Significance and Relevance of Citizenship Rights
III Citizenship Rights on The Arab Peninsula
A The Right to Citizenship and the Prohibition of Nationality Abrogation and Deportation
B The Acquisition of Citizenship
C Results and Comparison between the Arab Spring Countries
IV Civil Rights on the Arab Peninsula
A Civil Rights of Citizens in the GCC States
B Civil Rights of Non-Citizens in the GCC States
C Results and Comparison
V Conclusions and Outlook
5.4 Linguistic and Cultural Rights in the Arab Constitutions: From Arabism to Linguistic and Cultural Diversity
I Introduction: Cultural and Linguistic Rights in Arab Constitutions and in the Arab Spring
II Linguistic and Cultural Rights in the Maghreb Constitutions
A Cultural and Linguistic Rights in the Moroccan Constitution
1 From Governmental Recognition to Constitutional Recognition
2 Formalizing Tamazight in the 2011 Constitution
B The Algerian Constitution and Consideration of Tamazight as a National Language
C Constitutionalizing Tamazight in Libya and Tunisia
1 Libyan Constitution between Denial of, and Hesitation toward, Recognition
2 Tamazight and Formulation of a Draft Constitution after the Revolution
3 The Tunisian Constitution: The Possibility of Recognizing Amazigh Cultural and Linguistic Rights as a Component of Amazigh Identity
III Cultural and Linguistic Rights in the Constitutions of Arab Levant States
A The Iraqi Constitution
1 Iraqi Experience and Constitutional Recognition of Kurds’ Linguistic Rights
2 The Iraqi Constitution of October 15, 2005
B New Constitutional Experience in Syria and Jordan
1 The Jordanian Constitution: The Same Status as Before
2 New Constitutional Experience in Syria and the Prospects for Non-Arab Linguistic and Cultural Rights
IV Conclusion
5.5 Tunisia after the Arab Spring: Women’s Rights at Risk?
I The Privileged Status of Women Before the Arab Spring
A Family and Inheritance Law
B The Constitution of 1959
C Tunisia and CEDAW
II Impact of the Revolution
A During the First Transitional Period
1 The Withdrawal of the Reservations to CEDAW
2 Gender Parity in Electoral Law
B During the Second Transitional Period
1 The Attitude of the Islamist Party outside the Constitution Drafting
2 The Constitution Drafting Process
a The Status of Islam
b The Status of Women
c The Adoption of the Constitution
III Conclusion
5.6 Reflections on Women’s Rights in Yemen: Opportunities and Challenges
I Introduction
II Historical Background of the Status of Yemeni Women
III The Effectiveness of the Feminist Movement in Seeking the Advancement of Women and Sponsoring Their Problems
A Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women
B CEDAW and Yemeni Reservations
C Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the Yemeni Constitution
D Yemeni Women’s Participation in the Revolutionary Movement and the Harvest of Change
E Equality in the Yemeni Constitution and Demands for Achieving Gender Equality
F Women Participation in the National Dialogue Conference
G Major Challenges that Lie in the Way of Securing Women’s Entitlements in the Coming Period
H The Position of the Political Establishment (Official and Party-wise) on Women’s Issues
IV Constitutionalizing Women’s Rights
A Women’s Quota System for Their Representation
V The Discourse of the Islamic Movement on Women in Yemen
A The Problematic Nature of the Islamic Discourse on Women, between Extremism and Centrism
B The Islamic Parties and Their Approach of Duplicity in Dealing with Women’s Issues
C The Position on Women’s Labor
D The Position on Women’s Political Participation
VI Conclusion
5.7 Religious Minorities under Pressure: The Situation in Egypt, Iraq, and Syria
I Introduction
II Religious Minorities and National Laws
A Egypt
B Syria
C Iraq
III International Legal Mechanisms and the Protection of Minorities
IV Conclusion
5.8 Rights of Religious Minorities in Sudan
I Introduction
II Background and Context
III The Treatment of Religious Minorities in Sudan in Historical Perspective
IV Protection of Religious Minorities in the Sudanese Law
A Definition and Recognition of Minorities
1 Definition of Minorities under International Law
2 Definition of Minorities under the Sudanese Constitution of 2005
B Protection of the Rights of Religious Minorities under Sudanese Constitutions and Laws
1 Recognition and Protection of the Rights of Religious Minorities in the Old Sudanese Constitutions and the Interim National Constitution
a Recognition and Protection of the Rights of Religious Minorities in the Old Sudanese Constitutions 1953–1998
b Recognition of the Rights of Religious Minorities under the Interim National Constitution 2005
2 Recognition of Religious Rights under Sudanese Laws
a Recognition of Rights of Religious Minorities under the Criminal Law
b Recognition of the Rights of Religious Minorities under the Civil Law
V The Implementation of Religious, Cultural, Civil, Political, and Socio-Economic Rights of Religious Minorities in Practice
A The Special Commission for the Protection of the Rights of Non-Muslims in Khartoum
B Protection of the Rights of Religious Minorities in Practice
VI New Developments in Sudan: Secession of South Sudan
Part 6 Constitutional Courts: New Guardians of the Constitutions?
6.1 Constitutional Review in Arab CountriesDawn of a New Era?
I Introduction: Constitutional Review Prior to the Arab Spring
II Reforms of Constitutional Review in the Wake of the Arab Spring
A An Embattled Institution: The Egypt Constitutional Court from 2011 to 2014
1 The Court’s Role in the Immediate Aftermath of the Fall of the Mubārak Regime
2 Growing Confrontation with the Islamists
3 The Denouement: Restoration of the Court’s Role after the Fall of the Brotherhood
B Taking Constitutional Review Seriously: The Case of Tunisia
C Reforms from Above: Morocco and Jordan
1 Morocco
2 Jordan
III Conclusions
6.2 Morocco’s Constitutional Court after the 2011 Reforms
I Preface
II A Spirit
A The Distribution of Power
B The Promotion of Positivism
C Reconciliations
D The Deliberative Imperative
E References to Religion and Identity
III Engineering the Mechano-Institutional Space
A A Fertile Framework
B A New Statute
C New Competencies
D A New Procedure
E The Interpretations
IV Conclusion
6.3 The Mauritanian Constitutional Court after the Military Coup of 2008
I Introduction
II Regulation of Relations Between the Political Actors
A The Disagreement between Government and Parliament in 2008
B Amendments of the Rules of Procedures of the National Assembly
C Comments on the Rules of Procedure—Decisions of the Constitutional Council
III The Constitutional Arrangements for the Interim Head of State
A Plans for New Elections in 2009
B The Decision of the Constitutional Court on the Resignation of General Ūld ʿAbd al-ʿAzīz
C Article 40 as an Alternative Solution?
IV Oversight of the Presidential Elections to Overcome the Crisis
A The Dakar Framework Agreement
B The Decision of the Constitutional Court about Decree on Convocation of the Electorate
C The Elections of 2009
V Conclusion
6.4 Constitutional Reform and the Rise of Constitutional Adjudication in Jordan: Background, Issues, and Controversies
I The Backgrounds of the Reforms
II The Driving Forces Behind the Reform Process
III The Substance of the Reforms
A Prohibition of Torture (Art. 8.2)
B Protection of the Essence of Rights and Freedoms (Art. 128)
C Establishment of a Constitutional Court (Arts. 58–61)
D Judicial Power (Art. 98)
E Reform of the State Security Court (Art. 101)
F Provisional Laws (Art. 94)
G Dissolution of House of Representatives (Art. 74)
H The Constitutional Amendment of August 2014
1 Art. 67
2 Art. 127
IV Important Issues Ignored in the Reform Process
A The Senate as a Government-controlling Body
B Democratic Legitimization—The Elections
C The Prime Ministers and Their Governments
D The National Integrity Charter and the Dismissal of Judges
V Conclusion
6.5 An International Constitutional Court: Bulwark against the Erosion of Constitutional Democracy
I Introduction
II The Law of Democracy: Its Legitimacy and Superiority
A The Theoretical Superiority of Democratic Law
B The Practical Superiority of the Law of Democracy
III International Constitutional Law
A The Internationalization of Constitutional Law
B The Constitutionalization of International Law
C International Constitutional Law and International Protection of Human Rights
IV The International Constitutional Court
A Its Political Objective
B Its Composition
C Its Role and Submissions
D Its Powers
E The Proceedings
F The Applicable Law
V Conclusion
Part 7 International Influences and Interactions
7.1 The Relationship between International Law and National Law in New and Amended Arab Constitutions
I Introduction
II Theoretical Underpinnings
A Monism
B Dualism
C Criticism—Legal Pluralism
D Distinguishing Key Terms: Domestic Validity, Direct Applicability, Invocability, Direct Effect, and Self-Executory Treaties
E International Legal Provisions on the Relationship between International Law and National Law
III The Relationship Between Treaties and the National Legal Orders of Arab States with New or Amended Constitutions
A What Is the Scope of the Treaty-making Power of the Executive?
1 Bahrain
2 Egypt
3 Jordan
4 Morocco
5 Syria
6 Tunisia
7 Conclusion
B Do Treaties Become Part of the National Legal System? If So, When?
1 Domestic Validity
2 Direct Applicability in Courts
3 When Do Treaties Gain Domestic Legal Status?
a Direct Domestic Legal Force Once the Treaty Is Ratified and Enters into Force
b Direct Domestic Legal Force Once the Treaty Is Ratified and Enters into Force Plus Publication
c Indirect Domestic Legal Force
4 Policy Reasons for and against Direct Applicability of Treaties
C What Is the Constitutionally Recognized Role of the Legislature in the Treaty-making Process?
1 Bahrain
2 Egypt
3 Jordan
4 Morocco
5 Syria
6 Tunisia
7 Conclusion
D What Rank Do Treaties Have Internally?
1 Bahrain
2 Egypt
3 Jordan
4 Morocco
5 Syria
6 Tunisia
7 Conclusion
E Are the Constitutional Courts Authorized to Monitor Treaties?
1 Oversight by the Constitutional Courts over the Constitutionality of Treaties
a Morocco
b Tunisia
c Jordan
2 Constructing the Power of Oversight by Way of Interpretation?
a Repressive Oversight over the Constitutionality of Treaties that Require Parliamentary Approval
b Repressive Oversight over the Conformity of Ordinary Laws to Treaties
IV Conclusion
7.2 Turkish Constitutionalism: A Model for Reforms in Arab Countries?
I Introduction: A “Turkish Model” for Reform in the Arab World?
II Perceptions of the “Turkish Model”
III Characteristics of the Turkish Constitutional Order
IV Challenges to the “Turkish Model” Since the Arab Uprisings
A Revelations of the Gezi Protests and Their Aftermath
B Failed Constitutional Transition: 2007–2015
V Conclusion: The Limited Applicability of the “Turkish Model”
7.3 The Arab Spring and the Development of Islamic Constitutionalism in Iran
I Introduction
II Conditions for Muslim Revolutions
III Revolution for Islamic Theocracy or Constitutional Democracy
IV The Inter-Islamic Evolution of Modern Concepts of the State
V From the Revolution for Constitutionalism to the Absolute Rule of the ShĪʿite Jurist
VI Revolutionary Constitution-Making and Its Risks
VII Between Islamism and Republicanism: An Unresolved Dichotomy
VIII The Violence of Revolution and the Rule of Law
IX Conclusion and Prospects
7.4 Lessons from the Iraqi Constitution-making Process
I Introduction
II The Main Steps Toward an Iraqi Constitution
III Who Wrote the Constitution? Sunni Participation, the Constitutional Commission, and the Leadership Council
IV Utilizing Foreign Experts: Useful or Constraining?
V The Sectarian Crisis
VI Third-Party Influence: Between Meditation and Occupation
VII From Draft to Reality: Iraq’s Constitutional Development Since 2005
VIII Lessons from the Iraqi Constitutional Process
7.5 Impulses from the Arab Spring on the Palestinian State-Building Process
I Introduction
II Constitutional Deadlock
III Building State Institutions During Occupation
IV The Non-Member State Status at the Unga
V The Reconciliation Efforts
VI ḤamĀs Rule of Gaza
VII Pa Rule of the West Bank
VIII Conclusion
7.6 The European Union and the Constitution-making Processes in the Arab World: Observer or Actor?
I Introduction: Postcolonial Drift
II The Eu’s External Action and the Access to the Arab Region
A Common Policies, Principles, Actions, and Cooperation
B Neighbourhood Policy, Union for the Mediterranean, and Partnership for Democracy and Shared Prosperity
1 Views on the Barcelona Process
2 European Neighbourhood Policy and Union for the Mediterranean
3 Partnership for Democracy and Shared Prosperity
III Observation, Dialogue, and Influence
A The Quest for (Common) Values and for a Vision
B Supporting State Transition: Framework of Constitutional Processes
1 Democracy, Rule of Law, and Institution Building: Impact of the EU?
2 Security, Stability, Military: Ambivalence Test
C Relevance of Law and/or Politics in EU-Arab Relations
IV Conclusion and Prospects: The Eu’s Ambivalent Observer-Actor Status
Further Material
Epilogue: The Constitutional Legacy of the Arab Spring
I Introduction
II Egypt—The Failure of Islamization and the Return of the Military
III Tunisia—A Breakthrough for the Civil State?
IV Morocco—The Cautious Modernization of a Traditional Islamic Monarchy
V Conclusion
List of Contributors
Index
Sign up for alerts
Epilogue: The Constitutional Legacy of the Arab Spring
From:
Constitutionalism, Human Rights, and Islam after the Arab Spring
Rainer Grote, Tilmann J. Röder
Content type:
Book content
Product:
Oxford Constitutions of the World [OCW]
Published in print:
22 August 2016
ISBN:
9780190627645
Prev
|
Next
[3.81.25.170]
3.81.25.170